Just kidding but it sounds Gladwellian, right? Indeed it is. This is inferred from his Hiring and Mismatch Problem
"The mismatch problem shows itself all over the sports world. Although the study below was released in 2008, Gladwell has long illustrated the point that sports combines (events professional sports leagues hold for scouts to evaluate potential draftees based on a battery of 'tests') don't work. Gladwell's results echo what Michael Lewis talks about in Moneyball: Combines are a poor predictor of determining ultimate success. Mismatch problems transcend the sports world.
"The mismatch problem shows itself all over the sports world. Although the study below was released in 2008, Gladwell has long illustrated the point that sports combines (events professional sports leagues hold for scouts to evaluate potential draftees based on a battery of 'tests') don't work. Gladwell's results echo what Michael Lewis talks about in Moneyball: Combines are a poor predictor of determining ultimate success. Mismatch problems transcend the sports world.
Teachers are another example. While we tend to evaluate teachers based on high test scores, number of degrees and other credentials, that makes little difference in how well people actually teach.
Some companies, like Google, are trying to attack this problem. Google tried to find correlations between 'great' existing employees. When they find correlations, say like most people who score 9/10 on performance reviews, own a dog, they try to work that into their hiring. By constantly evaluating the actual results of their hiring, rethinking how they hire, and removing questions and evaluations that show no bearing on actual performance they are taking steps to try to eliminate the mismatch problem. Google also knows hiring lacks certainty; they are just trying to continuously improve and refine the process. Interestingly, very few workforces are so evidence-based."
After all Gertrude Stein's quote "I am I because my little dog knows me" is an universal truth.
No comments:
Post a Comment